The Silent Struggle: Why African, Caribbean, and Muslim Girls Aren't Seeking Mental Health Support

In the UK, a silent crisis has unfolded among young African, Caribbean, and Muslim girls. Despite facing significant mental health challenges, these groups are notably less likely to seek or receive the support they desperately need. This reluctance stems from a complex web of cultural stigma, systemic barriers, and societal pressures unique to their experiences.

As mental health issues continue to rise among youth, the gap in access and utilisation of services for these girls widens, potentially leading to long-term consequences. In this article we delve into the reasons behind their hesitance to seek help, the impact of this silence, and the urgent need for tailored interventions to address this critical issue.

At The Mentoring Lab Community C.I.C the MY HEALTH Mental Health Education Project seeks to address this complex web of barriers to accessing support.

Do black girls mental health issues stem from them not feeling beautiful or seen?

No, its deeper than this. That's why it's important to offer safe spaces where Black girls can explore topics around wellness and mental health with a wider lense. The MY Health project seeks to share research and data on Black Girls Mental Health, to better inform young people and their caregivers of contributing factors to mental health issues and most importantly where they can seek help. 

Learn More

The Scale of the Problem

Prevalence of Mental Health Issues
​According to a study by the National Health Service (NHS) in 2023, approximately 1 in 6 children aged 5 to 16 years old in England were identified as having a probable mental disorder. However, the rates were significantly higher among Black communities.

Disparity in Access
​The Mental Health Foundation reported in 2022 that Black British children were 10% less likely to access mental health services compared to their White British counterparts. This disparity was even more pronounced for girls from African, Caribbean, and Muslim backgrounds.

​Reasons for Reluctance

Despite the prevalence of mental health issues, many young African, Caribbean, and Muslim girls in the UK hesitate to seek support. This reluctance stems from various cultural, social, and systemic factors.

Cultural Stigma
A 2023 survey by Mind, a mental health charity in England and Wales, found that 68% of young Black and Muslim girls felt that seeking mental health support would be viewed negatively within their communities.

Lack of Cultural Competence in Services
The Race Equality Foundation highlighted in a 2024 report that only 9% of NHS mental health professionals in England identified as Black, Asian, or from other ethnic minority backgrounds, potentially leading to cultural misunderstandings and reduced trust.

Fear of Misdiagnosis
Research published in the British Journal of Psychiatry in 2023 indicated that Black individuals in the UK were 4 times more likely to be diagnosed with severe mental illnesses compared to White individuals, often due to cultural misinterpretation of symptoms.

Family Dynamics
A study by the University of Manchester in 2024 found that 45% of African and Caribbean girls aged 10-18 reported feeling pressured to handle emotional issues within the family, rather than seeking external support.
​
Religious Considerations
The Muslim Council of Britain conducted a survey in 2023 which revealed that 57% of young Muslim girls preferred to seek guidance from religious leaders rather than mental health professionals when dealing with emotional distress.

Consequences of Non-Engagement

Understanding these barriers is crucial, as non-engagement can lead to severe consequences, affecting their overall well-being and future prospects. Below we explore the consequences of non engagement on Black Girls mental health.

Escalation of Mental Health Issues
The Children's Commissioner for England reported in 2024 that untreated mental health problems in Black and Muslim girls were 30% more likely to escalate to severe conditions requiring intensive intervention.

Academic Impact
Data from the Department for Education in 2023 showed that Black and Muslim girls with untreated mental health issues were 25% more likely to experience a decline in academic performance compared to their peers who received support.

Long-term Health Outcomes
A longitudinal study by King's College London, published in 2024, suggested that African, Caribbean, and Muslim women who didn't receive mental health support in their youth were 40% more likely to experience chronic mental health conditions in adulthood.

What can we do to help?

Here are 5 things caregivers and parents can do to support the mental health of young African, Caribbean, and Muslim girls in the UK;

1. Open Dialogue
Create a safe, judgment-free space at home for discussing mental health. Encourage open conversations about emotions, stress, and well-being. This can help normalise mental health discussions and reduce stigma within the family unit.

2. Educate Themselves
Take the initiative to learn about common mental health issues affecting young girls, particularly those specific to their cultural background. This knowledge can help in recognising early signs of distress and understanding appropriate ways to offer support.

3. Seek Culturally Competent Support
Research and connect with mental health professionals or organizations that specialise in working with African, Caribbean, or Muslim communities. This can ensure that any professional help sought is culturally sensitive and appropriate.

4. Promote Positive Cultural Identity
Encourage pride in cultural heritage while also fostering an understanding of living in a multicultural society. This can help build resilience and self-esteem, which are crucial for good mental health.

5. Balance Cultural Expectations
Recognise the potential pressure of cultural expectations and find a healthy balance. This might involve moderating expectations around academic performance, household responsibilities, or social behavior, ensuring they don't come at the cost of the child's mental well-being.

These actions can help create a supportive environment that prioritises mental health while respecting cultural values and identities.

Conclusion

The reluctance of African, Caribbean, and Muslim girls in the UK to seek mental health support is a complex issue rooted in cultural, social, and systemic factors. Addressing this challenge requires a multi-faceted approach involving community engagement, culturally sensitive mental health services, and increased awareness campaigns tailored to these specific groups.

To combat this silent struggle, initiatives focusing on destigmatising mental health within these communities, increasing the diversity of mental health professionals, and developing culturally appropriate support systems are crucial.

By breaking down these barriers, we can ensure that young African, Caribbean, and Muslim girls in the UK receive the mental health support they need and deserve.

Register a young person today

MY HEALTH, is a Mental Health Education project, free to black girls, their parents, schools and community organisations.
Participants gain:
- Free group and one to one Youth Mentoring
- Befriending Trips
- Free Counselling for Black Girls and their Carer givers 

Learn More